Three boys were seen riding their bikes around the neighborhood of West Memphis, last seen heading to the Robin Hood Hill woods at 6:30. Its likely that Terry was already heading to Billy Stewarts home since, according to Billy, he was Terrys drug dealer at this time. Coincidence? How could she be so off in her description of what they wore and what they looked like, if she truly did see them? He died before he was finished being tied up. The problem with that is that Chris was under the carport cleaning at 5:30, according to both of his parents. As he leaned over Michael and removed his clothes, a hair from Terrys head or mustache fell onto Michaels body. I allege that these three women are correct in that they saw the three boys, I simply believe that they got confused on the time that it occurred. VICKIE: YES. As he jumped up from the fall, he grabbed Chris and apparently hit him with force as well. I recall a man was outside across the street working in his yard. Thats a time bomb. Terry Hobbs grew up working for his dad as a butcher; his job was to tie up cattle and hogs, transport them, butcher them and to possible even prepare and bind the meat. I'm a parent now and that's why this case has been glued in my mind. The three new witnesses were polygraphed about what . I think its open to interpretation. Why would either of these men lie about who they talked to that night unless they both were lying and couldnt get their stories straight? According to Terrys ex wife, Terry Hobbs first wife had claimed in their divorce papers that he molested their son. It puts all questions to rest. As I mentioned previously, this statement is an enormous indicator of truth, in my opinion. RIDGE OKAY, THATS WHAT IM GETTING TO, BUT YOU HAVE BEEN THERE ON OCCASION WITH BUDDY? I personally believe that this boy was Michael Moore. In Billy Stewarts statement, Terry had another drug dealer named Roy Taylor. (1). I've no doubt he killed Stevie to "get even" with Pam. However, therearesuspects and there is an abundance of evidence open to the public. The evidence that supports this theory is in the injury to Steve Branchs face and back of the head. 1 cop's mission: do whatever it takes to dissuade a focus on Terry. Stevens mother, Pamela Hobbs, worked a shift at the Catfish Island restaurant the day her son vanished. Terry Hobbs, the stepfather of eight-year-old victim Stevie Branch, has been named in documents released in Marian, Arkansas by the attorneys for Pam Hobbs, Stevie's mother. JMB really did love them even though he had a temper and did admit to corporal punishment. Here are two statements made by Narlene to police about LG. Meaning to me that he was the third one caught). AARON: ITS, ITS IN UH, ITS IN THOSE WOODS WHERE UH, WHERE THAT STOP SIGN IS AND ITS. (1) When Stevies autopsy was performed, a partially digested green-vegetable like substance was found in his belly. However, there is no mention of animal prints at the scene, as far as I know, nor car tracks found in the field next to those woods. The two teens jumped in the truck with the men, stopped by Billys home and bought the weed and then drove around the back streets of West Memphis, smoking and drinking whiskey. Richard took another polygraph saying that LG was not with him the night of the 5th and he passed. And why would Narlene have any need to lie for LG if he was innocent? Terrys own daughter allegedly told family members, including her mother, grandmother, cousin and aunt that she had been abused by her dad and two family members even claimed to have walked in on Terry abusing his daughter. I believe Terry would have changed altogether since he was at home but neither Jacoby or LG had that luxury just yet. He had LG and Buddy rip off the clothes of the boys and then pulled out a knife and began to bite and stab the scrotum of one boy. Turtles would be most attracted to areas that were soft and already leeching blood, according to experts and that is why it appears as though Chris groin had both stab wounds before death and animal predation wounds after death. And that 1 cop will know that a member of that community being subjected to questioning for a crime of this nature could lead down all sorts of paths: one of those paths being that Terry likes dick and is part of a small community that likes dick and that that 1 cop likes dick. There are so many rumors, lies and blatant ignorance surrounding this case. However, this was never corroborated by police. YOU JUST THOUGHT IT WAS BAD? Essentially, the statements made by Dr. Perretti are not much different than if Pam took her son to a doctor, had him examined and was then told by the doctor that Stevie had injuries related to sexual abuse. In part 3, when suing Natalie Maines, he said he wanted The Dixie Chicks to be "humiliated" as punishment when asked what he really wanted out of the lawsuit. AND UH, HE SAID AFTER WE HAD LEFT THE MOORES COMING OUT OF THEIR DOOR HE TOLD ME MAMA LETS GO TO THE CLUB HOUSE. You should see the other documentary WEST OF MEMPHIS There youll be more secure. 3:15 Michael Moore shows up and asks if he and Stevie can ride bikes together. I remember when the news broke and sitting in my living room floor crying and holding my new daughter I have read, watched and researched as much as I could throughout the years. Apparently, the medical examiner stated that the fine scratches on Stevies penis are similar to those from children who have sexually abused, i.e: given oral sex. I believe he intended to terrify and threaten them so they would never, ever speak of what they had seen. Even if he maybe didn't intend to kill him, I'm sure he started to beat him and his rage just got the best of him and there was no turning back. Tell me why Terry Hobbs DIDN'T do it - WM3 : r/UnresolvedMysteries - reddit I also believe that at some point during the attack, Stevie was hit on his leg by the edge/side of the board, and also possibly in his face, which I will discuss in a moment. It is clear to many experts that the left side of Stevies face had been bitten by turtles. DO YOU KNOW WHERE THE CLUB HOUSE WAS? SO WHAT HAPPENED NEXT? Its been so long ago you know it may not be in the right order but I know he did come over around 5:30/6 oclock and we played the guitar for a while and then he said he had to go. Neither Chris nor Michael had any facial injuries even remotely close to what Stevie had on his face. His alibi for the night of the murders was shaky (the friend he says he was with says he left for a while) and he acted strangely towards his wife when he went to pick her up from work, walking past her and not saying anything, just calling the police to report the boys missing. In recent years its been discovered that someones DNA was on Stevies penis. I learned from Roy Taylor that Mr. Hobbs was bisexual. Why in the world were the two men (or Terry alone) searching for the boys when it was light out if Terry had already said that Stevie could stay out till 8:00 pm? If a weapon had been used to create all the injuries then there would have been major cuts and lacerations with the contusions just like there was on the boys heads. The most likely answer is that Stevie, Chris and Michael were playing behind Jamie Ballards home probably right around 5:00 as they headed on there way to Stevies house. At first she claimed that this happened at 4:30 and at the murder trials, she claimed it was sometime after 5pm. Buddy allegedly confessed that when the four returned to the truck, Terry and David looked to the teens and promised to kill them if they ever spoke of the crime to anyone. Additionally, why would LG go down to the Laundromat at approx. RIDGE: DID YOU EVER SMELL THE SMOKE? Which means hecouldhave been walking with Buddy right at the time Terry and David would have shown up. Hobbs was sentenced to six months in prison for aggravated assault. When prosecutor John Fogelman interviewed Buddy later, Buddy repeatedly told him that he had an alibi for the 5th despite the fact that Fogelman never even brought it up himself. But the deeper I dug, the more I realized that not only was there no evidence to discredit that these four men committed this murder, all the known evidence supports the notion that they actually did do it. Terry Hobbs was born in 1958 and grew up in Northern Arkansas. After Terrys attack on Chris groin, was when, allegedly, David hit Chris till Buddy believed he was dead. ADVERTISEMENT These alleged confessions did not, and could not, comefrom intense online investigation. So the chance of them basing their statements off of the practically endless information found on the internet is nil. Hobbs was calling loudly at the children and ordering them to return to his house. Also, he may have searched for the boys in the woods around 5pm when he dropped Pam off at work, also when Terry was unaccounted for. Dixie came to work later and Linda Hollingsworth came in asking about where L.G. For years, the stepfather of one of the three children killed in West Memphis, Arkansas, has maintained his innocence, despite public outcry to investigate him. However, she drove a small four door car and there would be no room to pick up her sister if she already had six people in her car. YOUVE SEEN THE CLUB HOUSE, VICKIE: UH-HUH (YES) I HAVE SEEN IT SEVERAL TIMES. In 1993, he was married to Pamela Hobbs and was the step father of Stevie Branch. All experts agreed that Perettis autopsy reports were written exquisitely. When Aaron Hutchinson spoke about the clubhouse, he referenced the boards numerous times. (1) Its possible that the by the time the men could have entered into the woods, the three eight year old boys were already there hiding. One mystery that has plagued people who have followed the case, is why it appeared that Stevie and Chris were tortured while Michael was not. Either way, either one or two of the perpetrators decided it was necessary to actually get into the water to submerge the boys. She even described one brunette boy as being heavy set. Would they have admitted there were car tracks found and helped the defense win their case? The reason for this is because LG lived very close to both the Byers and the Moores. If we want to understand why those boys might have gotten killed in those woods we need not look further than Aarons own statements made to police shortly after the murders. I am not scared of that boy. Is there any other reason why hed admit on national television that he lied? That leaves many years unaccounted for. The question, however, is why wasChrisdegloved and not the other children? On Nov. 6 police in Memphis responded to a call that someone had been shot at 4460 Kerwin St., the home of Pamela and Terry Hobbs. -3:30 Christopher shows up looking for the boys. If anyone might know where the boys were going or what their plans had been for that day, it would most likely have been Aaron. Is there any reason NOT to believe Terry Hobbs is guilty of the murders other than simply believing that the West Memphis Three did it? The way the three boys were tied, wrist to ankle, as opposed to wrist to wrist, ankle to ankle, is one of the most unique aspects to this case. AARON: I THINK THEY WENT DOWN THERE. With all that in mind, I allege that Terry and Amanda returned home a little after 5pm. The reason why Chriss skin was removed but his penis remained, i.e. Did TH kill Stevie to "get even" or was it just his rage gone too far? When police told him they were going to polygraph him about Jessies alleged confession, Buddy immediately admitted that he had lied; Jessie never said anything to him about the murders. He had a history of crime and domestic violence, and he shot his brother-in-law, allegedly in self-defense. They did not have the ability to do an in depth search on the 5th because darkness was approaching. Just finished the trilogy and West of Memphis and I noticed something that made THE lightbulb off about him. The prosecution would mention a stick and Perreti kept saying, Or a 24. Listening now! VICKIE: YESYES I HAVERIDGE: AND WHEN WERE YOU THERE BEFORE? Shortly after this, Terry Hobbs noticed that the three boys were spying on the men. I went back and read all the autopsy reports and attempted to interpret them. Have you had a drug dealer named Ray? And finally, if Terry claims he never saw Stevie that day (despite statements from Jacoby, Jamie Ballard and her sister and mother) there is one extremely significant question Terry has to answer: why did Stevie have partially digested vegetables in his stomach? Even Aarons mother, Vicki, supported these statements in her first interview with police. On the north side of the pipe bridge, very close to the Blue Beacon woods, a woman on the service road saw the three boys riding their bicycles at approx. First of all, something led the perpetrators to get into the water. This is all supported by Mark Byers testimony. This is so hugely significant and yet lost on so many. Terry Hobbs was a violent man, this is proven and well documented, and the way Douglass pictures it, he likely wanted to punish or humiliate one or all of the boys and it went too far, leading him to murder them so they wouldn't be able to tell anyone. This is most likely when Stevie asked Terry if he could continue riding bikes with his friends. VICKIE: ARRON TOLD ME THAT UM HE AND MICHAEL AND CHRIS VISITED THEIR CLUB HOUSE EVERYDAY AND THEY ROAD THEIR BIKES AND THEY WERE SPYING ON 5 MEN AND AH I ASKED HIM WHO THEY WERE AND HE SAID I DONT KNOW MOM WHO THEY WERE I JUST YOU KNOW WE JUST SPYING ON EM I SAID WHY WOULD YOU BE SPYING ON 5 MEN YOU KNOW AND HE SAID WELL THEY WERE THERE EVERYDAY SO WE WOULD WATCH THEM. (source) LG had been job hunting that day and was likely wearing a shirt and tie for his interviews. Not only are their alibis remarkably different, they actually contradict and conflict with each other. The Puzzle of the West Memphis Murders And its about time we started putting some pressure on him for some real answers. He actually was able to get his friend and aunt to lie for him in order to protect him. I have questions. French reported that prior to the incident she had gone to the Hobbs' home after hearing what she believed to be a domestic dispute. Not only did Billy Stewart allege to have seen David and Terry kiss two different times, but he also claims to have delivered drugs to both men at a gay bar called J-Wags. The Blue Beacon Woods was connected to the Robin Hood Hills which was the last place the three boys had been spotted on the night of the 5th. "Yes I do have doubts. This gave the men 2 and a half hours to let off some steam and possibly drink and get high. Terry was born in Northern Arkansas and grew up in the Ozark Mountain region of the state. In 2011, the defendants were released from prison by accepting an Alford Plea, which allowed them to maintain their innocence and get out of prison, However, the plea didnt clear their convictions and all three men still have a murder charge on their record, despite their release from prison. And then, twenty years later, a letter is found that had been sitting untouched in the prosecutions possession for a year. If Terry wanted things to turn sexual, his predatory mind would have thought of ways to lead things in that direction. In both Billy and Bennies statements, i.e. I know there was a warning but the warning wasn't clear enough. According to many experts, this is a huge indicator that the perpetrator(s) knew the victims. Especially considering how extremely rare it is for a victim to be tied in this manner. Personally? (source) All of these interviews and statements show that not only did LG not have an alibi, but he lied about his alibi and asked other people to lie about being with him, too. They then picked Chris up (as evidence shows) and the three headed out on their bikes and skateboard, riding up 14th street right before 6pm. Additionally, his cousin, Charlotte claims that he was at Lakeshore before the murders, left and did not come back till the next day. What is most interesting, however, is that most of the public did not know that Chris was on a skateboard at one point that afternoon. This testing, though not as conclusive as traditional DNA testing, can help to exclude suspects as potential donors of physical evidence. Catch them! When the teens brought the boys back, one of them kicked Hobbs which sent him into a rage. He told police that Jessie had confessed to him and that he said that he had just held the boys while the others killed them. RIDGE: DID YOU EVER TELL ANYDODY ABOUT IT? Privacy Policy. Those who believe they are innocent claim it was a witch hunt due to Satanic Panic. If Terry truly had bitten and stabbed Chris scrotum, it would explain perfectly the questions around Chris death. VERY intriguing. When they arrived in the woods, Terry Hobbs told the boys to wrestle. With what we know about Stevie and how much he feared Terry, it seems impossible that Stevie would have been the child who kicked Terry. Whats more suspicious, is that Buddy originally told police that he was with his family barbecuing on the 5th but when his mother spoke to Fogelman, she never mentions anything about Buddy being home with her that night. I just can't get it out of my head. He is an evil man and true psychopath and the type of man to tie those boys the up the way they were found. If we have actualevidencethat the attacker did in fact bite Stevie in the face, then it is not a stretch of the imagination to think that the same attacker would also bite another child during the attack. Additionally, there is an ample amount of evidence, in my opinion, that Terry might have sexually abused all of his children. Douglas believes the act was meant to dominate, control, humiliate and punish. Before I summarize what the Guy/Stewart affidavits reveal, Id like to summarize the statements made by Aaron Hutchinson in his first two interviews. It appeared as though Christopher was tied up by one person, most likely David Jacoby, in my opinion, since his knots were all the same. Not even Damien, Jason or Jessie had any of that happen to them, and they were the ones who were falsely arrested for the crime. My feeling is that LG, thinking of a close and safe spot where he could go, would have asked Terry to drop him off at the Laundromat, less than a mile away from Terrys house. My theory is that Stevie finished dinner and took off with Michael again to find Chris, and Terry and Amanda then headed over to the Jacobys home. RIDGE: DID YOU EVER SMELL THE SMOKE? RIDGE: IT IS OKAY, YOUVE BEEN DOWN THERE BEFORE? After Stevie was gone, he expected her to get over it right away and said she was neglecting her wifely duties. Two private investigators looking into the case on their behalf eventually turned their sights on Terry Hobbs, Steve's stepfather, because his story did not add up -- he had claimed that he had begun searching for the boys at 6 pm on the day they had disappeared when in reality, they had only been reported missing at 9 pm. To corroborate this letter, Byers and Hicks lawyer and investigator contacted Bennies friend, Billy Stewart. 9pm the night of the 5th so we need to theorize what may have happened because he has no alibi. I believe that certainly Buddy, and perhaps LG as well, participated in the crime because of The Bystander Effect; they partook in the crime out of fear and/or compliance, but they did not have intentions to murder. Her relay of the conversation seems to reveal that Narlene is talking to LG as if they both know that Damien is guilty. I just find it amazing that she let this slip out and the police never even caught on. Terry showed up at his good friend Davids house to drop off Amanda so he and David could go buy marijuana. Currently, Hobbs has not been charged with anything related to the murders. Basically, he believes that Stevie was a sexualized child. I allege that Terry dropped LG off at 8:45 at the Laundromat/Flash Market on Ingram and proceeded to create an alibi for himself. [1]. This means that the four could have been driving around the back streets for around 25 minutes and then might have pulled up to the Blue Beacon Woods sometime around 6:40. They believed something inappropriate may be going on between the two, who practically lived together. subscribe to the Crime Stories with Nancy Grace podcast. Which means that when Natalies lawyers dug into Terry Hobbs past, there were obviously some people who made similar allegations to the ones Billy made 4 years later. I allege that the two perpetrators, Jacoby and Hobbs, entered the water and began to submerge the boys deep in the mud in order to keep them from floating. Hobbs was the stepfather of Steven Branch, one of the boys found murdered in 1993, in West Memphis, Arkansas. VICKIE: UM, WEST MEMPHIS POLICE HAD ALL OF THE AREA ROPED OFF, VICKIE: I WENT TO THE DEAD END IT WAS YOU KNOW. Further, I have another theory why the crime scene appeared so clean. Was it because he was running around frantically trying to cover up for the crime? If Terry had been spotted driving around with LG by either the Moores, Byers or any policemen who might have been in the vicinity, that could have raised some difficult questions for Terry to answer. Further, there is some belief that part of the injury to Stevies penis was also a bitemark. In the beginning I thought it was TH. We have a man, by his own admittance, who was in the spot where they crime occurred all night long. Terry admitted himself that he whipped Stevie and by Amandas own account, Terry was a violent man who left welts and bruises on her when he hit her. After ending his first marriage, he wed Pamela Hicks Branch in 1986, when her son Stevie was almost 2 years old. The 3 were let out of jail on an Alford Plea, which means that they admit that there is enough evidence to find them guilty (and thus the case is considered closed) but still maintain that they are innocent. In fact, she too brings up that Buddy was working that day as if that proved anything. When reading her first statements to police, it raises serious doubts about her alleged sighting of the three boys. Buddy told them that Billy Stewart was holding weed at that time. And in another statement made a week later, Aaron again says he believes his friends got caught spying on the men and one of them ordered the others to hold the boys while he killed them: AARON: NOBODY EVEN KNOWS THAT.. THAT I KNOW WHAT REALLY HAPPENED. I actually believe there is a good possibility that at least LG already knew the two men. He most likely began to tie up one side of Stevie using a figure eight knot and then went to Michael and tied up one side of him with a square knot. On top of Terry possibly molesting Stevie and being very jealous of him, I've no doubt Pam kissing another man and then the subsequent murders is just glaring motive. I understood that Terry had not previously called the police to report that Stevie was missing.. Its also interesting that Narlene is claiming that Damiens mother is lying about Damien being with her. He systematically destroyed every member of his family, traumatizing them with years of extreme sexual abuse/grooming and beatings. AND I TOLD HIM, YOU KNOW WHAT WHY DIDNT YAWL LEAVE WHY DIDNT YOU COME HOME, WERE YOU SCARED? Calhoun County man still missing - WJHG I learned through my connection in the drug-trade that Mr. Hobbs preferred sexwith young boys. LG never mentioned whether he was dropped off at home or not, but I have a theory about what happened next, which I will now describe. -5:00 Terry Hobbs drops Pam off at work and returns home What happened next is a theory supported by evidence and interviews. According to Clemente, suspects who have something to hide, such as evidence, or signs of abuse at the home, will not want police to search their residence and will attempt to put distance between themselves and where the abuse took place. RIDGE: WHAT ARE YOU TALKING ABOUT DEAD ON?